SecondChanceInfosecondchanceinfo.com

Eviction-Friendly Apartments in Buffalo, NY

Last updated:

Renting After an Eviction in Buffalo

Buffalo offers remarkably affordable rents compared to other New York cities, and the city's revitalization has brought new housing investments while maintaining a large stock of older homes and apartments. New York State's strong tenant protections, including eviction record sealing provisions, provide meaningful tools for renters with past evictions. Private landlords in neighborhoods like the West Side, East Side, and South Buffalo are often the most accessible options.

New York Eviction Record Laws

Eviction Record Sealing
Available. New York State enacted legislation to seal eviction records in certain circumstances, including cases that were dismissed, discontinued, or decided in the tenant's favor. Sealed records cannot be disclosed by courts to screening companies.
Screening Lookback Period
Most landlords check eviction history for the past 7 years. New York's sealing law may limit what appears on screening reports for eligible cases.
Tenant Screening Restrictions
New York State has source-of-income discrimination protections, prohibiting landlords from refusing tenants based on lawful source of income, including Section 8 vouchers. Additional protections exist under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act.

Housing Options in Buffalo After an Eviction

Likelihood indicates how likely each option is to accept applicants with eviction records.

TypeDescriptionLikelihood
Private landlords in doubles and triplesBuffalo's classic double and triple homes are widely rented by individual owners who typically screen informally and value direct relationships.high
LIHTC / tax credit apartmentsBuffalo has multiple affordable housing developments funded through tax credits with income-based eligibility and more flexible screening.moderate
Second-chance housing programsSome Buffalo-area property managers partner with nonprofits to accept tenants with housing barriers through structured programs.moderate
Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority (BMHA)BMHA manages public housing and Housing Choice Vouchers. Applications are reviewed individually, with eviction history considered in context.low
Transitional housingPrograms through the Salvation Army, Community Action, and Compass House provide transitional housing with support services.moderate
Room rentals and shared housingRoom rentals are affordable and widely available in Buffalo, particularly near UB South Campus and in the Elmwood Village area.high

Strategies for Renting with an Eviction in Buffalo

  1. 1.

    Check if your eviction qualifies for sealing

    Under New York law, eviction cases that were dismissed or decided in your favor may be sealed. Contact Neighborhood Legal Services to check your eligibility.

  2. 2.

    Target private landlords on the West Side and East Side

    Buffalo's West Side, East Side, and South Buffalo have many owner-occupied doubles and triples where landlords often prefer personal references over formal screening.

  3. 3.

    Leverage source-of-income protections

    New York law prohibits landlords from refusing your Housing Choice Voucher. If a landlord refuses, report it to the Division of Human Rights.

  4. 4.

    Offer to pay a larger security deposit

    Under New York law, security deposits are capped at one month's rent for most rentals. Consider offering to prepay the first and last months' rent instead.

  5. 5.

    Use housing navigation services

    Buffalo's Homeless Alliance and Community Action Organization provide housing navigation to connect individuals with willing landlords.

  6. 6.

    Build a renter resume

    Prepare references, income documentation, and a letter explaining your circumstances to present a complete picture to prospective landlords.

Local Housing Resources in Buffalo

Organizations that can help you find housing after an eviction.

Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority (BMHA)

Housing Authority

Operates public housing and administers Housing Choice Voucher programs in the City of Buffalo.

(716) 855-6736website245 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo, NY 14201

Neighborhood Legal Services

Legal Aid

Provides free legal assistance to low-income residents in Western New York, including eviction defense and record sealing help.

(716) 847-0650website

Homeless Alliance of Western New York

Housing Navigation

Coordinates homeless services and housing programs throughout Erie County, including rapid rehousing and housing navigation.

(716) 853-1101website

211 WNY

Helpline

Dial 211 for referrals to housing, rental assistance, emergency shelter, and other community resources in Western New York.

211website

Tips for Renting with an Eviction in Buffalo

  • 1.Contact Neighborhood Legal Services to see if your eviction record qualifies for sealing under New York law.
  • 2.New York caps security deposits at one month's rent — offer to prepay additional months instead to reassure landlords.
  • 3.Buffalo's doubles and triples are your best bet. Drive through the West Side and South Buffalo looking for 'For Rent' signs.
  • 4.Know your rights: New York landlords cannot refuse your Housing Choice Voucher or other lawful income source.
  • 5.Buffalo's rental market is highly seasonal — search in winter months for the best selection and most flexible terms.
  • 6.Contact the Homeless Alliance of Western New York for rapid rehousing assistance if you need immediate help.
  • 7.Join local Buffalo rental groups on Facebook where private landlords post directly.
  • 8.Consider the surrounding towns of Cheektowaga, Tonawanda, and Lackawanna for additional affordable options.

Average Rent in Buffalo

$950

/month (1BR)

$1,200

/month (2BR)

With subsidized housing (LIHTC or Section 8), you typically pay 30% of your adjusted gross income — often significantly less than market rate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I rent an apartment in Buffalo with an eviction on my record?
Yes. Buffalo's affordable market and large stock of private rentals create good opportunities. New York's eviction record sealing law and source-of-income protections provide additional tools.
How long does an eviction stay on my record in New York?
Eviction filings can appear on screening reports for up to 7 years. New York law allows sealing of certain eviction records, which removes them from public access.
Can I seal my eviction record in New York?
Yes. New York allows sealing of eviction records that were dismissed, discontinued, or decided in the tenant's favor. Contact Neighborhood Legal Services for assistance.
Does Buffalo have source-of-income protections?
Yes. New York State law prohibits landlords from refusing tenants based on lawful source of income, including Housing Choice Vouchers and other government assistance.
What neighborhoods in Buffalo are best for eviction-friendly rentals?
The West Side, East Side, South Buffalo, and Black Rock neighborhoods have many private landlords in doubles and triples who screen informally.
Where can I find free legal help for eviction issues in Buffalo?
Neighborhood Legal Services provides free legal services to low-income Western New York residents, including eviction defense and record sealing assistance.

Related Resources

Related Resources on This Site

More for your state

Helpful guides

Disclaimer: This is informational only, not legal advice. Eviction laws, tenant screening practices, and housing availability change frequently. Always contact properties directly to confirm current policies. An eviction on your record does not automatically disqualify you from housing — many landlords evaluate applicants individually. For legal advice about your eviction record or tenant rights, contact a legal aid organization or a HUD-approved housing counselor.

Sources