Judges consider both aggravating factors (which increase the sentence) and mitigating factors (which decrease it).
Aggravating factors:
Use of a weapon. Firearms enhancements can add years to a sentence.
Amount of harm or loss. In fraud cases, the loss amount directly increases the offense level. In drug cases, the quantity determines the base level.
Vulnerable victims. Offenses targeting elderly, disabled, or child victims receive higher sentences.
Leadership role. Organizers, leaders, or supervisors in criminal activity get a 2-4 level increase.
Obstruction of justice. Lying to investigators, tampering with witnesses, or destroying evidence adds 2 levels.
Prior criminal history. More prior convictions mean a higher criminal history category and longer sentence.
Breach of trust. Crimes committed by public officials, licensed professionals, or fiduciaries receive an enhancement.
Mitigating factors:
Minor role. If you were a minimal or minor participant in the offense, you may receive a 2-4 level decrease.
Acceptance of responsibility. Pleading guilty and demonstrating remorse typically earns a 2-3 level reduction.
Cooperation. Providing substantial assistance to the government can result in a motion under USSG 5K1.1 (federal) that allows the judge to go below the guideline range or even below a mandatory minimum.
Mental health and substance abuse. A history of mental illness, trauma, or substance abuse can be presented as a mitigating factor.
Age and health. Elderly defendants or those with serious health conditions may receive lower sentences.
Family responsibilities. Being a primary caretaker for children or dependents can be a mitigating factor, though courts have been inconsistent on this.
Military service, employment history, community ties. These can demonstrate that a shorter sentence is sufficient.
Since Booker made the guidelines advisory, judges have broader discretion to consider individual circumstances under 18 U.S.C. 3553(a), which directs courts to consider the nature of the offense, the defendant's history, the need for deterrence, protection of the public, and the need to avoid unwarranted sentencing disparities.